February 15

Best Pellet Stove On The Market (2020)

Buying Guides


Before you find the “best pellet stove”, you have to be aware of the aspects that make it as such. Pellet stoves can vary in features, size, consumption, etc., so you must be extremely careful to not end up with a product you’ve overpaid for. 

There are a few things that go into making the best pellet stove out there, and we’ll tackle them all for you in our guide. Before we delve into the specs, we will review 5 pellet stoves that are definitely worth your attention. 

Best Pellet Stove

If you’re having trouble assessing which pellet stoves are the highest-rated at the moment, we’re happy to tell you that this problem of yours is about to be solved. Choose any of the following 3 and you’ll be all set. 

Winner: Comfortbilt Pellet Stove HP22 

Comfortbilt’s product is currently among the top-rated pellet stoves and is by far the best pellet stove for the money. Why do we say that? For starters, it has a burn efficiency of 86% and 50,000 BTU

  • Sturdy construction 
  • Huge capacity for pellets
  • plus
    More affordable than most pellet stoves
  • plus
    50,000 BTU 
  • plus
    It has a thermostat 
  • plus
  • plus
     Leaves little to no ash
  • plus
    Looks beautiful 

It goes without saying that you won’t find these features in many stoves, let alone in those who sell for this price (in the range of $2k). The stove is endowed, like many others of this sort, with a thermostat and an auto-ignition feature. 

The problem with many pellet stoves is that they sound like waterfalls when they’re functioning. This one is surprisingly quiet for its size. Moreover, soot doesn’t stick to it as easily as it would on others, so it won’t need too much cleaning. 

Comfortbilt Pellet Stove HP22- 50,000 BTU

Source: comfortbilt.net


The hopper is situated on top of the stove and can be filled with up to 55 pounds of pellets. Due to its high BTU, the pellets are burned so quickly and efficiently that sometimes you’ll be tempted to believe that the ashtray is almost useless. 

Many manufacturers lie about the effectiveness of their stoves for marketing purposes and that’s why we were inclined to believe that the claim that it can warm up to 2.000 sq. feet was just smoke and mirrors. 

We stand corrected now. It really does warm up that huge space. In fact, it does it in as little as an hour. Installation is a piece of cake and you don’t need to pay anyone to do it for you. 

Two other huge perks of the Comfortbilt HP22 are its outstanding design and fantastic craftsmanship. The stove is well-built, there’s not a shred of a doubt about that. 

The window is generous, so you can enjoy that ghost-fire on the floor during those cold nights. All things considered, this is indeed the best wood pellet stove you can get for approx. $2k. It’s worth every penny. 

Runner-Up: Castle 12327 Serenity Wood Pellet Stove

As mentioned previously, the best-rated pellet stoves can come in various shapes and sizes. Castle’s stove is a thinner one, perfect for rather small houses. Whereas the winner of our top had a burn efficiency of almost 90%, the Castle’s is 69.8%. 

  • Affordable
  • “Slim fit”, to put it like this
  • plus
    Capacity of 40 pounds 
  • plus
    Works as described 

Considering its size, that’s not as bad as you might think. It can easily warm up to 1,500 sq. feet in 60 minutes. One thing we have to mention is that this has different modes you can use for various results. 

This is a quite nice feature. Apart from the thermostat, it has a few heating options that will definitely come in handy. The 12327 has a BTU of 31,960 and a hopper with a capacity of 40 pounds. 

Castle 12327 Serenity Wood Pellet Stove

Source: castlestoves.com


This particular stove sells for just a little over $1k, which is pretty unbelievable if you ask us, given that it’s got such nice specs. While most stoves come with unintelligible installation instructions, the ones that come with this product are crystal-clear. 

The design is really nothing out of the ordinary, but this doesn’t mean it looks bad. The item weighs around 180 pounds, which makes it one of the heaviest pellet stoves we’ve ever come across. 

This, however, also kind of means it’s durable. This didn’t get the first place because it comes with a few drawbacks or… let’s call them shortcomings. 

The ashtray, for instance, has one of the worst designs we’ve ever seen and makes it impossible to get the ash out without spilling some on the floor. Another inconvenience is that it heats up like lava. 

You really can’t stand next to it after a couple of hours but hey, that’s probably more proof that it’s as efficient as the manufacturer states it is. The bottom line is that this is a good pellet stove, in spite of a few things that could have been improved. 

Alternative: Pleasant Hearth Medium Pellet Stove 

35,000 BTUs and a hopper with a capacity of 40 pounds. This is what you get from this Pleasant Hearth which – brace yourself – it’s actually a pretty pleasant hearth. Other features you will certainly find great are: 

  • Beautiful design
  • Very powerful and efficient 
  • plus
    5 heating settings 
  • plus
    Runs smoothly and quietly

Automatic ignition, continuous functioning (on either the MAX setting or the MIN) and no less than 5 different settings for heat; its BTUs account for the fact that it can warm up to 1,800 sq. feet. The burning efficiency of this Pleasant Hearth model is 85%. 

It looks like it is a tiny stove, but its power makes up for its size. As you might expect, you can adjust the temperature as you please. The major drawback is its price: well above $1,500. 

Pleasant Hearth Medium Pellet Stove

Source: ghpgroupinc.com


The temperature can be set by turning the knob back and forth. It’s actually that simple. This will come in handy for the elderly, who might not be best friends with the complex thermostats that are usually put on these stoves. 

In terms of design, the Pleasant Hearth looks fantastic. It’s got a chrome finish to it and a quite generous window that will allow you to see that mesmerizing fire during a cold winter’s night. 

You can install the stove yourself by following the instructions, which is yet another plus. When the desired temperature has been met, the stove turns off automatically; if the temperature drops, it turns on. In this fashion, it works just like a gas heating central. 

If you’re having trouble with noise, we’re glad to tell you that this is extremely quiet for its size. A less pleasing aspect is that almost half of the pellet stove reviews made on this particular model put it in a negative light. 

Some people complained about the unit, saying it stopped working after one month or even less. We’re sure that these are isolated cases, though. 

2nd Alternative: Summers Heat SHP10 Pellet Stove 

Summers Heat isn’t a famous brand of pellet stoves, but we thought this particular model deserved to be in this top. The SHP10 can warm up to 1,500 sq. feet and can work continuously up to 20 consecutive hours. 

  • Affordable 
  • Efficient
  • plus
    The window is hard ceramic
  • plus
    Runs smoothly and quietly

Like all other pellet stoves, it has got automatic ignition and a thermostat you can use to set the temperature. The hopper can accommodate a maximum of 40 pounds of pellets. Its main selling point is that it can engorge on pellets of any size. 

In comparison with the other pellet stoves we’ve reviewed until now, this won’t allow you to program it. It’s somehow understandable when you look at the price. This isn’t supposed to be anything fancy. It’s one of the simplest pellet stoves out there. 

Summers Heat SHP10 Pellet Stove On White Background

Source: walmart.com


As with pretty much any other product, the pellet stove reviews for this one are both good and bad. For some, it’s a great buy. For others, it’s anything but. It’s true that it’s got a few shortcomings. 

For instance, it lacks an ashtray, so you’ll have to use a vacuum. Another downside is that it can get loud. Functionality also seems to be impaired in some cases, as the stove shuts down when it shouldn’t do that. 

Considering that it’s worth just a little above $1,000, it’s somehow clear that this won’t be a top of the line product, all the more so since the manufacturer isn’t very known in this industry. 

If you haven’t got too much money and you’re not aiming for a state-of-the-art stove, this could do. However, if you’d like a durable, hassle-free product, you might want to continue shopping around. 

Best Portable Pellet Stove 

Here is our top pick for the best portable pellet stove:

US Stove BSK1000 Stove Kit 

This product right here isn’t designed to be used in a house, but for heating up a cabin, for example, or a lodge somewhere in the woods, where you’re off the gas grid. You should keep in mind that this isn’t a stove per se.

  • The most affordable DIY pellet stove kit  
  • Made out of cast iron
  • plus
    Quick and effortless installation 

It’s a kit that allows you to get a stove by “tweaking” a steel drum. The drum is not included, so you’ll have to purchase it individually. 

The kit has everything you need to get a DIY stove: legs to support the barrel, a flue collar and pieces of hardware intended for the mounting of the stove. The kicker is that this comes with a price tag of around $50. 

US Stove Iron Cast Pellet Stove Kit

Source: homedepot.com


This is a really feasible deal if you ask us. After you’ve put your rudimentary stove together, you must have chopped wood or wood pellets at the ready. You can use the stove in a garage, as well. 

Moreover, if you have some kind of workshop where it’s extremely cold, this is the heating solution you’ve been looking for. 

As you might expect, you will need a couple of professional tools to transform the steel drum in a stove, so we wouldn’t recommend you go a few kilometers deep into the woods only to realize you won’t be able to build it. 

The best pellet stove reviews we’re researched say that this is one of the cheapest heating “on the go” solutions you’ll ever come across. The biggest perk of this kit is that it’s all cast iron. 

You can be convinced that this will last you. 

Why You Should Choose A Pellet Stove Over Other Heating Solutions

There are many reasons why a pellet stove is considerably better than most other heating solutions available on the market. For the time being, we’ll focus on the two most important reasons: 


A pellet stove is much cheaper than a gas or electric stove and does not pose as many operating costs as those two. The price of a pellet stove can range from $1,000 to over $4,000, but that’s still affordable in comparison with the price you’d pay for a gas stove. 

A pellet stove uses less electricity than both electric and gas stoves. Most of them need electrical current only to ignite the fire. This way, you save a lot of money you’d pay on bills. 

Taking Money From Wallet

The price of a ton of wood pellets is somewhere around $200. That’s a ton – we’re talking about a huge number of pellets. The price isn’t that bad. During the winter season, you might need 3 or 4 tons of pellets. 

Subsequently, you’ll need to pay in the range of $1,000 to heat your house all throughout the winter. How much would it cost you to use a gas or electric stove in a season? 

You probably don’t even want to think about it because you know you’ll get a migraine. This is the main reason why many people get rid of their gas central heating in favor of a good wood pellet stove. You should definitely do the same if your bills are cosmic. 

Pellets Availability 

There will be pellets for as long as companies that work with wood will exist, so… always. Pellets are extremely cheap, and you can get them from a variety of sources. Most people purchase them straight from the Internet. They will get to you packed carefully in bags. 

So, given that there’s a huge availability, you’ve got plenty of choices. Just make sure you don’t purchase pellets that are bigger than the auger of your stove can handle. 

You can even make your own pellets if you’ve got a business that deals with wood. All you need in order to make that happen is a wood press and then you’re all set. 

If you’ve read our previous guide, you will have seen that pellets can be made out of a lot of other materials, from dead leaves to grass. 

On What To Pay Attention When Choosing Your Pellet Stove

There are a few crucial things you must keep in mind when you’re shopping around for the best pellet stove on the market. Overlooking them can get you in trouble, as you can easily end up with a stove that won’t work properly or will not cut it for you. 

In the following, we’ll provide a list of things you should keep in mind the next time you’re on the run for a great pellet stove.


1 BTU is the unit that represents the amount of heat 1 pound of water needs in order to get to 10F. A pellet stove with 25,000 BTU, for example, can heat up to 1,200 square feet. 

A stove with 50,000 BTU can heat up double that area. Assess the space you need to heat up in order to purchase a pellet stove with the right number of BTU. There are plenty of online calculators you can use to get the exact number of BTU. 

The manufacturer, too, can give you some more insights into how many BTUs your stove should have in order to heat up your house properly. 


The size of the pellet stove you’re about to get should be chosen in lines with how much available space you’ve got in your house. There are stoves that are designed horizontally and stoves that are developed more on the vertical. 

Pellet Stoves Different Sizes

This can make a huge difference in respect with how much space you’ll have left after the stove has been installed. It doesn’t apply in all cases, but sometimes, the larger the stove is, the more power it has. 

Pay attention to the fact that size is interconnected with weight. The larger the stove is, the heavier it will be. You might need a couple of able-bodied men to move it to the room where it’s going to be installed. 

Container Size 

This refers to how many pounds of wood pellets you can put into it. Commonly, medium-sized pellet stoves have hoppers with a capacity of around 40 pounds of pellets. Again, the larger the stove is, the bigger its capacity will be. 

Before you make a decision, give yourself some time to peruse the reviews that have been written for that particular model. This way, you’ll see whether the capacity is as specified by the manufacturer or not. 

It can happen that some of them will say anything just to sell more products. Always read reviews before you purchase a stove or any other product from the Internet, for that matter. 

Ease Of Cleaning 

90% of all wood pellet stoves have ashtrays that allow you to get rid of the ashes quickly. Unfortunately, there are some stoves that don’t have such a thing, so you’ll need to purchase an ash vacuum. 

Pellet stoves don’t generally require too much effort when it comes to cleaning. All you need is a chimney brush and a vacuum. The glass and the exterior can be cleaned with soapy water. 

If possible, try not to purchase a stove that doesn’t have a tray for the ashes. Granted, pellets don’t leave as many ashes as chopped wood, for instance, but it’s simply better to rest assured you can get rid of the waste instantly. 


Who makes the best pellet stove? If we base our opinion solely on this buying guide, we declare that the best manufacturer at the moment is Comfortbilt. As you’ve seen, their stove is almost pristine. 

Our wood pellet stoves review on that particular model revealed the fact that Comfortbilt doesn’t make any compromises when it comes to endowing their stoves with top features while keeping them in the affordable range. 

Pellet Stove In Room

Apart from the 5 brief reviews on top products, we’ve also tackled a few key-aspects you should look at when you’ve found a stove that you consider purchasing. 

Since the reviews we’ve enclosed in this buying guide are somehow short, you might not be 100% convinced that they’re a good deal. Don’t sweat it, we’ve got you covered. In the next sections, we’ll present you 4 in-depth reviews. 

They will be written for 4 best stoves you can get these days. We hope this buying guide cleared out some of the issues you might have had in regard to understanding why you shouldn’t make a hasty decision. 

A stove should be a life-long investment, not a product for which you’ll have to invest money every half a year or so. Stay tuned for the reviews! 

About the author 

Jett Jenkins

You may also like

Your Extensive Guide To The Pellet Stove

Comfortbilt HP22 Pellet Stove Review

Pleasant Hearth Medium Pellet Stove Review

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}

Subscribe to our newsletter now!